Five of the eleven logos certify nothing
Four payment logos and one helpline logo sit on the sample page with the same size, colour and caption style as the examined marks. Each of them is a true statement about a relationship and none of them is a statement about the operator.
- Payment logos
- 4 of 11
- Helpline logo
- 1 of 11
- What they assert
- a relationship, not a finding
- What they prove
- that a relationship exists
The four logos, and what each one actually asserts
A logo is not dishonest. It is simply being read as stronger than it is, because it travels in the same visual language as marks that were examined. The correction is to state the claim each one makes, exactly.
What each logo on the sample page asserts, and nothing morecard scheme logo "deposits with this scheme are accepted here"
it does not mean the scheme examined the operator
bank transfer logo "bank transfers are accepted"
it does not mean a bank endorsed the operator
e-wallet logo "this wallet can be used"
it does not mean the wallet vets the operator
crypto logo "this network is supported"
it does not mean the network knows who the operator is
helpline logo "this site displays a helpline's name"
it does not mean the operator met a standard to
display it, or that it contributes to the helpline
The last row is the one worth pausing on, because it is the strongest of the five and the most confusable with a mark. Displaying a helpline is a real act, and it is also compatible with any operator behaviour whatsoever: no examination stands behind it, and there is no scheme to satisfy.
Where a logo sits, and why that placement is the message
The payment row
Payment logos are placed in a row near the deposit control, where they do the job they are there for: telling a reader which method will work. A seal dropped into the same row borrows the row’s practicality and lends nothing back.
The footer band
A footer band is where a page puts everything it wants to look complete. Because the band is skimmed rather than read, a mixed row of licence numbers, payment logos, seals and helplines is read as one thing: this page is normal.
The honest caption
None of this requires a page to stop showing logos. It requires the caption above a group not to say something the group does not support. A row headed “we accept” is accurate for payment logos. The same row under a heading about safety is not, and the heading is where the misleading happens - not in the logos.